Tuesday, 11 January 2011

Camera Lucida: Reflections On Photography - Roland Barthes


“[A photograph] makes me lift my head, allows me compute life, death, the inexorable extinction of the generations...I am the reference of every photograph, and this is what generates my astonishment in addressing myself to the fundamental question: why is it that I am alive here and now?”


Roland Barthes was not a photographer, and never claimed to be so. He had no formal training, and never even took up photography as an amateur. So, for this book, his “reflections on photography”, Barthes, the legendary French philosopher and literary theorist, approaches the subject merely as an observer, an interested party. Camera Lucida was written, as Barthes himself stated, because he “wanted to learn at all costs what photography was 'in itself'”.

Whether or not he succeeded is, I suppose, up the reader. Regardless, his journey contains numerous interesting diversions, complex ideas and startling epiphanies. Camera Lucida touches on – among other things - the debate about the so-called “death of painting”, mortality, memory, the emotional effect of photographs and how they “work” (such as, what catches one's attention in certain photographs, and why – to this end it contains prints of various photographs he discusses).


It is by no means an easy read (Barthes' writings can sometimes be unapproachable, so often does he touch upon ideas almost inexplicable, such are the constraints of language) and in the end it is bleaker than you may perhaps expect, but what remains is not the bleakness of Barthes' conclusions, but the wonder at his ideas, his theories, and ultimately, the realisation of how amazing photography truly is. It is amazing in a way that is difficult to express, so I will leave the great man himself to provide an example:

“One day, quite some time ago, I happened on a photograph of Napoleon's youngest brother, Jerome, taken in 1852. And I realised then, with an amazement I have been unable to lessen since: 'I am looking at eyes that looked at the Emperor.'”

No comments:

Post a Comment