Monday, 31 January 2011

Thus Spake Zarathustra - Friedrich Nietzsche


In many ways, Thus Spake Zarathustra felt like a book I had already read. It felt familiar – not the small things, the details, but the big picture. Despite having not read the book I am familiar with Nietzschean thought (via other books and well-read friends), but the familiarity did not detract from my enjoyment or my occasional wonder during reading.

Nietzsche put his ideas mouth of Zarathustra the prophet and ideas he espouses remain important, interesting and sometimes controversial today. Probably the most controversial – and most infamous – of the ideas is that of the “Ubermensch”, infamous of course for the alleged connections with Nazism, but these days the only people who make that connection are those who have have never read Nietzsche. The idea has nothing to do with a master race, but it is the idea that human beings are merely a “bridge” between animals and an evolved life-form still to come – the Ubermensch. Humans will only reach the level of the Ubermensch by means of spiritual evolution, becoming completely in command of their fears and insecurities, and moving beyond the need for fripperies such as religion. “God is dead,” as Zarathustra famously says. The only God we need is ourselves.

For this and other ideas – such as eternal recurrence, the theory that history is repeating over and over – Thus Spake Zarathustra is well worth reading, if you're at all interested in philosophy then it's an essential text, and one that I cannot do justice in a short review.

(Finally, a word on the translation – my copy is the Thomas Common translation, written as classic English, giving it a pseudo-Biblical feel. While this fits well, it can be difficult to grasp at times. I believe other translations available may “update” the language somewhat).

Monday, 24 January 2011

On Bookshops

My favourite local bookshop closed down recently.

It was a wonderful old place; a Victorian-era house converted into a bookshop by way of filling every room with tables and chairs, stacked with old volumes committed to scaly yellow paper, shelves taller than a man can reach, looming out from beneath high ceilings.

I loved it all; the dry woodsy smell of old paper, the labyrinthine corridors, rooms upon rooms of books, the creaky floorboards and the absurdly small staircase leading to the second floor, full of the classics and mysterious unknown volumes in Latin that, I sometimes liked to think, had not been read for over a hundred years...

It's closed now. Converted with unseemly haste into a generic furniture shop; the old-timey charm gone, replaced now with bright lights, slick sheen and polish.

I'm partly to blame, I know. I loved the place and went there frequently, but nonetheless I still chose the easy option too often. Online book retailers are numerous and it's too easy just to point, click and buy. No need to put on shoes and leave the house, to brave the rain, wind or cold, no need to go out and hope they would have the book you wanted. Online, they always have the book you want. And so it's easier, and beyond that it's oftentimes cheaper, and so I understand why I made the decision to go for the one-click buy online option and I understand why others do, and will continue to do so.

But nonetheless I will feel a pang of guilt and regret every time I walk past that place, and think about the happy hours whiled away running my finger along the dusty old covers, the exhilaration of spotting that hidden gem amongst the endless shelves, and sense of being at home there that I will never get online...

Book purchasing may be cheaper for me now, but it will never again be as much fun. And so, all I ask is that you buy your books from your local bookshops, too. It might be a bit more expensive, but believe me, you'll miss them when they are gone.

Tuesday, 11 January 2011

Camera Lucida: Reflections On Photography - Roland Barthes


“[A photograph] makes me lift my head, allows me compute life, death, the inexorable extinction of the generations...I am the reference of every photograph, and this is what generates my astonishment in addressing myself to the fundamental question: why is it that I am alive here and now?”


Roland Barthes was not a photographer, and never claimed to be so. He had no formal training, and never even took up photography as an amateur. So, for this book, his “reflections on photography”, Barthes, the legendary French philosopher and literary theorist, approaches the subject merely as an observer, an interested party. Camera Lucida was written, as Barthes himself stated, because he “wanted to learn at all costs what photography was 'in itself'”.

Whether or not he succeeded is, I suppose, up the reader. Regardless, his journey contains numerous interesting diversions, complex ideas and startling epiphanies. Camera Lucida touches on – among other things - the debate about the so-called “death of painting”, mortality, memory, the emotional effect of photographs and how they “work” (such as, what catches one's attention in certain photographs, and why – to this end it contains prints of various photographs he discusses).


It is by no means an easy read (Barthes' writings can sometimes be unapproachable, so often does he touch upon ideas almost inexplicable, such are the constraints of language) and in the end it is bleaker than you may perhaps expect, but what remains is not the bleakness of Barthes' conclusions, but the wonder at his ideas, his theories, and ultimately, the realisation of how amazing photography truly is. It is amazing in a way that is difficult to express, so I will leave the great man himself to provide an example:

“One day, quite some time ago, I happened on a photograph of Napoleon's youngest brother, Jerome, taken in 1852. And I realised then, with an amazement I have been unable to lessen since: 'I am looking at eyes that looked at the Emperor.'”

Thursday, 6 January 2011

The Street Of Crocodiles - Bruno Schulz


Ah, The Street Of Crocodiles. A contradiction of a book (at once hilarious and sombre, wistful and eccentric, startling vivid and beautifully vague), this too-short novel from arguably the greatest writer Poland has ever produced (with apologies to Mr. Kapuscinski and Mr. Conrad) is a wonderful (mostly)fictional tale of the author's childhood in the eponymous street in Drogobych, Poland.

Actually, calling this a novel is not quite true. It is, in actually, a collection of short stories, but they all revolve around Schulz's childhood and hang together so well that this feels like a unified work.

Schulz's vivid, eccentric style is what makes this all work so well, his startling use of metaphor cannot be rivalled (except, perhaps, by Leonard Cohen on his rare forays into literature); descriptions of “sides of meat with their keyboard of ribs”, people of a hot day wearing “that grimace of heat”, a garden that “crackled in the fire of the afternoon”, birds covering the local church like “living black leaves” leap from the page - as do many others - and will make these stories stick in your mind for some time after the book is finished.

The real fascination to be had in The Street Of Crocodiles though, is with the Father. He is a central character in most of the stories, and even in the ones for which he is absent, his presence is still felt. A charismatic, maddening character, he is a shopkeeper who becomes so obsessed with cockroaches he begins to resemble one, a man who imports rare birds' eggs and begins to live with – and like – the birds, and a man who believes that tailors' mannequins should be treated no different from humans.

Schulz could easily treat such character with mockery, with disdain, but he does not. Throughout the Father, despite all his insanities, is drawn with great warmth, and rather than come across simply as a deranged lunatic, we see him as a man with perhaps too much intelligence to remain sane during the “perpetual greyness of dusk” into which Drogobych would often sink. He was, as Schulz writes, a man conducting a “colourful and splendid counteroffensive of fantasy...against the trenches and defenseworks of a sterile and empty winter”.

It is a great tragedy that, following his death at the hands of the Nazis in 1942, so little remains of Bruno Schulz's writing. What we do have, we should cherish, and The Street Of Crocodiles we should cherish most of all. It will not take long to read, but will be remembered for a lifetime.

Sunday, 2 January 2011

VALIS - Philip K. Dick


"It is sometimes an appropriate response to reality to go insane"

(I should mention before even starting, that summarising VALIS in a way that makes any kind of sense is nigh-on impossible, but I shall give it a go...)

Reading VALIS, Philip K. Dick's semi-autobiographical opus, feels a little bit like falling down the rabbit hole. Calling it a sci-fi novel would be doing it a disservice. There's not much science here, and it's not entirely fiction either. VALIS is about many things – religion, time, cruelty, faith, cynicism, and madness – and I'm not sure how to classify it, exactly, but sci-fi isn't quite right.

VALIS is narrated by the author himself (who is a character in the book) but the novel deals principally with Horselover Fat. He was already mentally unstable when, in March 1974, he was “hit” in the head by a beam of pink light – which he dubs “Zebra”, but what others later call VALIS (Vast Active Living Intelligence System) - causing him to hallucinate and gain hitherto unknown knowledge. Fat believed this was a direct communication with God. Not the creator God (who, he apparently learned during his visions, was blind and insane), but the true God. Soon after, Fat begins searching for meaning in all of this, he writes a rambling journal (that he dubs his “exegesis”) detailing the knowledge he had gained (extracts from this litter the novel) and believes the Saviour has been born again. He makes it his life's goal to find the Saviour.

It should be pointed out that Horselover is clearly insane. We can be fairly certain of that, but to what degree we can never be sure. In fact, it is not Horselover at all, but our narrator and author Dick himself. As he reveals early on, “I am Horselover Fat” (etymology geeks might recognise that “Philip” originates from the ancient Greek word for “Horselover” while “Dick” is German for “Fat”). Fat is an alternate personality of the clearly unstable Dick, and yet throughout he is treated as a separate character, conversing with the other characters (and the narrator himself) as if he truly exists. With this in mind, it would be easy to dismiss Dick/Fat's “revelation” with the beam of pink light to be nothing more than a further breakdown, a psychosis, but the novel does not make this easy.

Around a third of the way through, Dick and two friends – Kevin, the group's resident cynic, and David, a devout Catholic – watch a science fiction film named Valis, which contains so many elements similar to Dick's own experience with the pink light to dismissed. They meet the makers of the film, rock star Eric Lampton and his wife Linda, and their friend, the terminally ill electronic musician Brent Mini. All three claim to have experienced the same communication with the pink light – VALIS – that Dick did (indeed, Mini's illness stems from radiation poising caused by over-exposure to VALIS) and, even more extraordinarily, the Lamptons claim to have sired a child, a two-year old girl named Sophia, who is the Saviour.

Come the end of the book, we are left wondering about so much. Such as - while Dick may be unstable, was his experience with VALIS real? If not, are the Lamptons and Mini similarly deranged? What of their daughter? Is she the Saviour, merely a precocious young child, or as insane as her parents? Is there a true God, or should we, as Sophia claims, worship only ourselves? If there is a true God and a creator God, and the creator is insane, then are we living in an meaningless, insane, unstable universe? If so, is there any point in ongoing search for meaning in such a universe?

I'm still mulling over the answers to the questions – these and many, many others – that VALIS poses. Philip K. Dick died in 1982, the year after VALIS was published. I wonder if he was able to figure any of it out...