
I'm not usually a fan of the historical fiction genre, but fell in love with Ron Hansen's richly detailed, meditative Western novel (made into the 2006 film of the same name). It's not, as you might expect, about crime, it's not even really about the act of the assassination itself. It's a novel dealing with universal themes of loyalty, betrayal, love, obession, greed and, perhaps unexpectedly, fame.
Jesse James – presented as a charismatic, moody character, beguiled by his own fame and tortured by his demons. He achieves larger-than-life, quasi-mythical status in his own lifetime (“ever since I was younger, Jesse James has been as tall as a tree”, spits a bitter Bob Ford at one point) takes the young, wily, intelligent and insecure Bob Ford under his wing, alternately kind and cruel to the young man who worships him as a hero. Their curious, tense relationship is explored in great detail here, and seems that neither is sure what they – or the other one – wants from it. “Do you want to be like me?” James asks Ford, “or do you want to be me?”
Ford's obsession only grows (he is described as watching James' mannerisms as if “preparing an impersonation”) but soon mutates into something close to hatred (or fear) when he realises the man is not the hero he had perhaps thought. The assassination itself is odd and somewhat ambiguous. Did James know it was to happen – did he cultivate Ford's hatred so that it would, to preserve his fame and legend? What motivated Ford? Hatred? Fear? Greed? The book largely leaves these questions open to interpretation, little more than hints given. In the end, perhaps the answers don't really matter. The motivations are perhaps not as interesting as the people themselves, and the American public's reaction to them. James and his gang – thieves and murderers, albeit charismatic and exciting ones – are shown to be worshipped as counter-culture heroes by large sections of the public and media. Following his assassination, James is martyred while Ford – despite ridding the country of its public enemy #1, is forever remembered as the coward of the novel's title.
In the end, was he a coward, in doing what no one else until that point had the courage or conviction to do? Was James, in seemingly cultivating his own death, the true coward here, unable to face is comeuppance at the hands of the ever-encroaching forces of law enforcement?
At the end of this wonderful novel, you may well be plagued by these and the other questions posed, but more than that, that awe-inspiring prose, beautiful descriptive work and rich detail will remain with you. If only all works of historical fiction could be as stunning as this.