
Are you instinctively annoyed by a novel that does nothing but asks questions? If so, why might this be? Can a book with no characters and no plot even be called a novel? By asking this question in the very title, is Padgett Powell acknowledging this, and if so, what do you think his opinion would be? If we agree that this is not a novel, then what it is? What would be required for this to become a novel? Does it actually matter whether it is, or is not, a novel? Is it not more important that Powell's latest involves the reader directly, in a way that none have before or since or that the reader is confronted with questions about themselves, their lives, what they have done and not done? Do you consider it any way relevant or important that the book can be read in a day, but will be thought about for many days afterwards? Should the author not be lavished in praise for trying to do something uniquely different with the form? Would you rather read the same kind of thing you have read before, or something totally new? If you answered the former, why is that? If you agreed with the latter, shouldn't you already be making the moves to purchase this book?